In 2019, my research about the SHSAT was published in a peer-reviewed journal and discussed in the NY Times, Wall Street Journal, and elsewhere. In the article, Fairness to Gifted Girls: Admissions to NYC’s Elite Public High School, I reported that the SHSAT was unfair to girls, in that it under-predicted how girls performed in high school. I suggested that an index combining SHSAT scores and middle school grades would be a fairer admissions criterion than the SHSAT and overall a better predictor of high school grades. Applying that index to the cohort that took the SHSAT in 2012 would have resulted in the admission of a Brooklyn Tech class that was 57% girls.
Jonathan Taylor • Feb 20, 2025 at 5:46 pm
In 2019, my research about the SHSAT was published in a peer-reviewed journal and discussed in the NY Times, Wall Street Journal, and elsewhere. In the article, Fairness to Gifted Girls: Admissions to NYC’s Elite Public High School, I reported that the SHSAT was unfair to girls, in that it under-predicted how girls performed in high school. I suggested that an index combining SHSAT scores and middle school grades would be a fairer admissions criterion than the SHSAT and overall a better predictor of high school grades. Applying that index to the cohort that took the SHSAT in 2012 would have resulted in the admission of a Brooklyn Tech class that was 57% girls.
Jonathan Taylor
Jessica • Feb 4, 2025 at 3:16 pm
Wow! Beautiful writing.
Angela Belcher Epps • Oct 14, 2025 at 3:52 pm
Ellie Bar-Lev, you’ve captured the relevant aspects of “The Original 9’s” journey. Thank you for your interest in our experiences. Very nice job!